December 31, 2012 Deadline Looms Under Tax Code for Fixing Severance Agreements with Releases


Employers have until the end of the year to take advantage of relief from penalties under section 409A of the Internal Revenue Code for agreements that require employees to sign releases before severance benefits are paid. Section 409A was enacted in 2004 to regulate deferred compensation.  Internal Revenue Service ("IRS") regulations made clear that it would affect not only traditional deferred compensation arrangements, but also arrangements previously not thought of as deferred compensation. Severance and change-in-control benefits are often subject to the section 409A requirements. Employees pay most of the price for mistakes that result in violations of section 409A, including a 20 percent tax penalty.

The IRS surprised many in early 2010 when it announced that agreements that require the employee to sign a release of claims (or non-competition or non-solicitation agreement) before severance or change-in-control payments start may run afoul of section 409A because they give the employee some control over when payments will start, sometimes allowing the employee to choose which year payments will be made. Industry push-back persuaded the IRS to provide transition relief, the last of which will end on December 31, 2012. This relief allows employers to modify agreements to deal with such release requirements to specify when payments will be made and what happens if a release is not signed on time. The transition relief allows correction of agreements with these problems – even if payments have already started – something not otherwise available. In addition, the employer is not forced to notify the employee of the documentary violation of section 409A and the employee does not have to attach a notice to the employee’s personal income tax return about the violation. After December 31, 2012, this relief will no longer be available.

If you are interested in a more detailed discussion of this relief and the required changes to employee releases, check out Stoel Rives' recent Client Alert on the subject.


Fred Has a Very Bad Day (Termination Checklist and Guide)

Unless your life’s ambition is to reprise George Clooney’s role in Up In The Air, Part II, you probably don’t like having to fire people. But someone’s got to do it . . . and it has to be done right. Here are some things to consider before you step into that room to do the dirty deed. (Pronouns are a nuisance, so our terminated employee will be known as Fred .)


  • Has the decision been properly vetted by everyone who should participate? You may simply be the “implementer,” not the “decider,” so make sure you have buy-in from all the relevant stakeholders.
  • Particularly when the decision is prompted by misconduct, poor performance or something else Fred did,  have you gotten his side of the story? Even if you end up finding Fred’s version a little less than credible, wouldn’t you rather know now what he has to say for himself, rather than read it for the first time in a Summons and Complaint?
  • Has the basis for the decision been properly documented? Most, if not all, employment lawsuits could be avoided if the employer took the time to properly document the performance faults, the efforts made to remedy performance (i.e., notice to Fred of his poor performance), and the legitimate business reasons for the termination decision.
  • Have you reviewed Fred’s file to determine whether he has any post-employment obligations such as a covenant to not compete, or to not solicit your customers or your employees, or a confidentiality agreement? If such agreements exist, be sure to give Fred another copy of the document and remind him of his continuing obligations. 
  • Will you offer severance? If so, more often than not, you will want to have an appropriate release to give Fred to consider. There are occasions when you will want to offer severance but not require a release of claims, but that rarely happens these days.
  • If you are going to have a written separation agreement (and you don’t have to have one), have you considered other provisions that might induce Fred to sign the release, like:
    • A letter of recommendation;
    • An agreement to not oppose an unemployment benefits application;
    • An agreement to reimburse Fred for a certain amount of COBRA expenses, etc?
  • Similarly, if you are going to have a written agreement, have you included all the provisions you need, in addition to the release of claims, like:
    • A non-disparagement clause;
    • An agreement to not reapply (watch out – these clauses can be tricky);
    • An acknowledgement of continuing confidentiality duties;
    • A promise to return all company property;
    • If Fred is over forty, all of the provisions necessary to comply with OWBPA?   
  • Will you conduct the termination meeting alone or with a witness? The advantage of having a witness there is that he or she can take notes and be the corroborating witness should things go south. The disadvantage is that the presence of the silent witness may irritate Fred. Nine times out of 10, you’ll want the witness.
  • Have you advised your trusted IT person to sever Fred’s computer access (including remote access) during the time that you will be meeting with him? Rarely will you want the employee to work at all after the termination meeting. If the meeting is delayed, be sure to tell the IT person.
  • Have you considered when to schedule the meeting? Best is near or at the end of the day. Your office or Fred’s office is fine, but it might be easier to meet in Fred’s office or a conference room so that you can leave if Fred wants to argue and you need to end the meeting. It is easier to leave Fred’s office than to try to make him leave your office. Wherever you choose, make sure it is private.
  • During the meeting: Don’t beat around the bush. Be direct, but gentle. Give a reason, but don’t go into detail. Resist being drawn into an argument. State that the decision has been made, is final, and won’t be reconsidered. Acknowledge Fred’s pain. Sensitive, caring companies get sued less often than cold, heartless ones.
  • If Fred claims he is being or has been discriminated or retaliated against for some unlawful reason, (as opposed to just complaining that the decision isn’t right or isn’t fair) ask him to tell you very specifically why he says that, make careful notes of what he says, tell him that you will investigate the claim and get back to him, but that the decision stands. Call your lawyer.
  • Tell Fred that his computer access has been cut off. Explain that you will work with him to get any personal information off his computer.
  • Ask for Fred’s keys, card access, phone, laptop, thumb drive, or whatever other company property he has. Ask him if he has any company property or documents at home. Ask him if he ever emailed himself company documents. If he has materials at home, arrange a time to pick those things up. If he sent himself documents at home, get his assurance that he will delete those emails. You may need to take more serious steps than these if you suspect that Fred is not being straight with you.
  • Decide in advance how Fred will collect his personal items. Will you walk him back to his desk and watch him pack? Will you agree to meet him at the office on the weekend?
  • Regardless of whether you offer benefits in exchange for a release, give Fred a letter that says he has been terminated and reminds him of any post-termination obligations, if any. (Some states require that you state the reason for the termination.)
  • Know what final pay is due and when it is due. State rules vary a lot. Do you have to pay out unused vacation upon termination? Depends. Do you have to pay out unused sick leave? Depends. When is the final paycheck due? Depends on whether Fred quits with or without notice or is fired or leaves by mutual agreement. In Oregon, because he was fired, Fred is entitled to receive his final pay no later than the end of the first business day following his termination. During the termination meeting, you should ask Fred whether he will come in to pick up his check or whether he wants you to mail it to him.
  • Do your final paperwork or take steps to see that it gets done.
  • Go home. Have a drink.